SCOUTTEAM
● LIVE|2023 SEASON|FBS PERCENTILES|
HOME›SLATE›2023›WEEK 8›MICH @ MSU›OVERVIEWMARKET FIGURES ARE BOOK CONSENSUS, NEVER MODEL OUTPUT
SITE
F1SLATEF2LEADERSF3TEAMSF4PORTALF5RECRUIT
THIS WEEK
BC @ GT76
JMU @ MRSH73
PITT @ WAKE73
PSU @ OSU72
MINN @ IOWA72
MEM @ UAB69
MSST @ ARK68
TOL @ M-OH67
MICH @ MSU67
CLEM @ MIA67
MISS @ AUB66
TTU @ BYU66
TCU @ KSU65
RICE @ TLSA64
SC @ MIZ64
CLT @ ECU63
TENN @ ALA63
WSU @ ORE63
OKST @ WVU62
TEX @ HOU62
GAST @ UL62
ASU @ WASH62
BAY @ CIN60
USU @ SJSU60
NU @ NEB59
UTSA @ FAU59
SMU @ TEM58
RUTG @ IU58
DUKE @ FSU58
UCF @ OU57
NMSU @ UTEP56
USM @ USA55
WIS @ ILL55
UCLA @ STAN55
UTAH @ USC53
WKU @ JXST52
AKR @ BGSU52
HAW @ UNM52
UVA @ UNC51
MTSU @ LIB50
AF @ NAVY50
ARMY @ LSU50
CSU @ UNLV49
CCU @ ARST46
APP @ ODU46
EMU @ NIU45
USF @ CONN44
FIU @ SHSU43
BUF @ KENT42
WMU @ OHIO40
CMU @ BALL40
UNT @ TULN37
NEV @ SDSU34
ULM @ GASO22
FIDELITY
MEASURED
DERIVED
≈ ESTIMATED
DOT MARKS
MICHIGAN
MICHIGAN STATE
OVERVIEWPRESEASON PROFILE
MATCHUPHEAD TO HEAD
TEAMROOMS & PLAYERS
VINTAGE2023
SAT 19:30 ET|SPARTAN STADIUMCONFTENSIONVACATEDTALENT GAP9|O/U46.0COLLISION
75
AP · FPI
TEAM
PTS
2025
TAL
OFF
DEF
RET
PACE
SOS ▾
IMP
ML
SPREAD
AWAY
#1AP
1FPI
MICHB1GMICHIGAN
49
15-0
91
88
95
78%
21
90
35.3
-4500
-24.5
HOME
—AP
81FPI
MSUB1GMICHIGAN STATE
0
4-8
81
20
69
21%
15
73
10.8
+1700
+24.5
IMP = IMPLIED TEAM TOTAL FROM SPREAD + O/U · OFF AND DEF ARE SCOUT TEAM GRADES AS FBS PERCENTILES · EVERY MEASURED FIGURE IS 2023CONSENSUS · DRAFTKINGS
FINALMICH49—MSU0
CLOSED MICH -24.5TOTAL 46.0MICH COVERED · 49 POINTS · OVER
MICH
OFFICIAL BOX SCORE
MSU
49
POINTS
0
477
TOTAL YARDS
182
357 (28-35)
PASSING
133 (16-29)
120 (34)
RUSHING
49 (29)
28
FIRST DOWNS
10
7-11
THIRD DOWN
6-16
0-0
FOURTH DOWN
0-3
34:31
TIME OF POSS.
25:29
7-75
PENALTIES
11-102
0
TURNOVERS
2
3
SACKS
1
2
QB HURRIES
0
MICH
DERIVED · PLAY BY PLAY
MSU
0.458
SEASON 0.305
EPA / PLAY
-0.086
SEASON 0.069
54.8%
SEASON 49.3%
SUCCESS RATE
26.4%
SEASON 37.5%
19.4%
SEASON 16.4%
EXPLOSIVE RATE
7.5%
SEASON 11.1%
6.73
SEASON 6.22
YARDS / PLAY
3.32
SEASON 4.84
-0.086
SEASON 0.052
EPA ALLOWED
0.458
SEASON 0.203
26.4%
SEASON 33.7%
SUCCESS ALLOWED
54.8%
SEASON 43.7%
7.5%
SEASON 10.5%
EXPLOSIVE ALLOWED
19.4%
SEASON 14.5%
33.3%
SEASON 20.1%
STUFF RATE
23.1%
SEASON 14.8%
OFFICIAL FIGURES ARE THE BOX SCORE AS SCORED. DERIVED FIGURES COME FROM PLAY BY PLAY WITH GARBAGE TIME REMOVED, SO THEY COUNT A DIFFERENT SET OF PLAYS AND WILL NOT TIE OUT AGAINST THE OFFICIAL COLUMN. A BRIGHTENED SIDE LEADS THAT ROW BY THE DIRECTION IN ITS TOOLTIP; TIME OF POSSESSION IS UNMARKED BECAUSE IT IS A TENDENCY, NOT A VIRTUE. SEASON AVERAGES ARE REGULAR SEASON ONLY. MARKET FIGURES ARE BOOK CONSENSUS, NEVER MODEL OUTPUT.
DATA BASISNOTHING ON THIS TAB IS MEASURED YET · 2023 PRESEASON · NO GAMES PLAYED
MEASURED0 OF 12 GAMES
Real 2026 data. It accumulates weekly and replaces carried figures metric by metric, on the schedules below.
CARRIED14 ROOMS
What each roster did last season, applied player by player. Transfers name the school.
PROGRAM PRIOR2 STAFFS
The programme's own prior identity — or, where the staff is new, the coach's career fingerprint with its sample.
PRESEASON FACT7 PER TEAM
Talent, recruiting, vacated usage, portal and coach status. Preseason inputs.
ABSENT2 CLASSES
Current season luck and situational splits. Shown absent with the reason, never estimated.
FLIPS TO MEASUREDABSENTNOT MEASURED. This asks how many weeks into a season each number becomes trustworthy, which is a within-season question. The back-test measures relationships between one season and the next, so it cannot answer it.
MARKET LINE VS TEAM PROFILEGAME LEVEL · WEEK 8 FIELD n=54
MARKET
TOTAL46.0
SPREADMICH -24.5
IMPLIED — MICH35.3
IMPLIED — MSU10.8
SCORING ENVIRONMENT
32FBS PCTL
BOTH OFF × BOTH DEF
BY MARKET TOTAL
39 / 54
BY ENVIRONMENT
47 / 54
DISAGREEMENT8 SLOTSThe two rankings disagree by 8 positions on a 54-game board. Both figures are stated; the site does not resolve which is right.
PACE COLLISION
SLOW × SLOW
MICH PACE29.3s
21
MSU PACE29.6s
15
SHARED PACE29.5s
18
PLAY VOLUME122
18
CEILING CHARACTERIDENTITY · NOT QUALITY
MICH30CEILING
EXPLOSIVE
26
PROE
44
TEMPO
21
EXPLOSIVE26p
26
PROE44p
44
TEMPO21p
21
MSU26CEILING
EXPLOSIVE
11
PROE
53
TEMPO
15
EXPLOSIVE11p
11
PROE53p
53
TEMPO15p
15
IS THE RECORD REAL2023 · FULL SEASON
MICHRECORD MATCHES
13-0ACTUALvs12.5-0.5FROM SCORING
GAP TO SCORING PROFILE+0.5 W
ONE SCORE RECORD2-0
POINT MARGIN / GAME+27.2
MICHIGAN won 13 of 13 against a scoring profile describing 12.5. Both are facts about the same season; the market prices the first.
MSURECORD OVERSTATES
4-8ACTUALvs2.4-9.6FROM SCORING
GAP TO SCORING PROFILE+1.6 W
ONE SCORE RECORD2-1
POINT MARGIN / GAME-12.4
MICHIGAN STATE won 4 of 12 against a scoring profile describing 2.4. Both are facts about the same season; the market prices the first.
TEAM LEDGERMICHIGANMICHIGAN STATE2023 PRESEASON · NO GAMES PLAYED
VACATED USAGE — AND DID THE ROSTER REFILL ITOPEN VOLUME IS A FACT, NOT AN ASSIGNMENT
VACATED USAGE BY ROOMLEFT OPEN, LARGEST FIRST
WR/TE52%Luke SchoonmakerTE · 19% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONRonnie BellWR · 14% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONJoel HonigfordTE · 9% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONROTATION6 FURTHER DEPARTURES
LB40%R.J. MotenPORTAL · FLORIDA · 16% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONMike MorrisLB · 13% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONTaylor UpshawPORTAL · ARIZONA · 10% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONROTATION1 FURTHER DEPARTURE
OL35%Olusegun OluwatimiOL · 18% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONRyan HayesOL · 16% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONROTATION2 FURTHER DEPARTURES
DL33%Mazi SmithDL · 21% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONEyabi Okie-AnomaPORTAL · CHARLOTTE · 9% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONROTATION2 FURTHER DEPARTURES
DB31%DJ TurnerDB · 19% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONGemon GreenDB · 12% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONROTATION1 FURTHER DEPARTURE
QB9%Cade McNamaraPORTAL · IOWA · 7% OF ROOM PARTICIPATIONROTATION2 FURTHER DEPARTURES
RB4%Isaiah GashRB · 4% OF ROOM PARTICIPATION
SHARE OF LAST SEASON'S ROOM PARTICIPATION THAT DEPARTED, LARGEST FIRST · OPEN VOLUME IS A FACT, NOT AN ASSIGNMENT
PORTAL & CLASS INTAKE — WHO CAME INHEADCOUNT, NOT A PROJECTION
WR/TEAJ Barner · PORTAL ★4 · INDIANAKarmello English · SIGNEE ★4Deakon Tonielli · SIGNEE ★42 MORE ARRIVALSREFILLED
LBErnest Hausmann · PORTAL ★4 · NEBRASKASemaj Bridgeman · SIGNEE ★4REFILLED
OLLaDarius Henderson · PORTAL ★4 · ARIZONA STATEDrake Nugent · PORTAL ★4 · STANFORDMyles Hinton · PORTAL ★4 · STANFORD3 MORE ARRIVALSREFILLED
DLJosaiah Stewart · PORTAL ★4 · COASTAL CAROLINAEnow Etta · SIGNEE ★4Cameron Brandt · SIGNEE ★32 MORE ARRIVALSREFILLED
DBJosh Wallace · PORTAL ★3 · MASSACHUSETTSJyaire Hill · SIGNEE ★4Cam Calhoun · SIGNEE ★4REFILLED
QBNO STARTING ROLE OPENEDINTACT
RBCole Cabana · SIGNEE ★4INTACT
PORTAL AND SIGNING-CLASS ARRIVALS AT EACH ROOM THAT LOST VOLUME · A HEADCOUNT, NEVER A USAGE PROJECTION
CARRIED GRADES & TEAM FACTS — THIS ROSTER, TODAYCARRIED FROM 2025, RE-HOMED PLAYER BY PLAYER · MICHIGAN
CARRIED COMPOSITE
59.673 PCTL
CARRIED OFFENSE
65.677 PCTL
CARRIED DEFENSE
55.756 PCTL
ROOM
GRADE
FBS PCTL
OPP-ADJ
TAL
RET
N
OBS
QB6969939364 OF 6 GRADED
RB424294971110 OF 11 GRADED
WR/TE575786672918 OF 29 GRADED
OL595992632115 OF 21 GRADED
DL757587872415 OF 24 GRADED
LB606083801810 OF 18 GRADED
DB646480672418 OF 24 GRADED
TEAM FACTS — FULLY KNOWN NOWPRESEASON FACT
TALENT COMPOSITE91st91
BLUE-CHIP RATIO47%89
RECRUITING CLASS#17 · 11/27 BC88
CLASS RANK TREND-7 · 3 CYCLES36
PORTAL NET BLUE-CHIP+3 · 9 IN / 13 OUT—
COACH STATUSRETURNING · 8th YR—
DEV TRANSITION MIX18%3
EVERY ROW HERE IS KNOWABLE TODAY — NONE OF IT WAITS ON A GAME
COACH PRIOR — WHO APPLIES, AND WHAT A CHANGE MOVESBASIS · PROGRAM PRIOR
MSUHARLON BARNETTFIRST SEASON1 SEASON · 1 PROGRAMME
A new staff, so the coach's own career fingerprint stands in for the programme's prior season.
PASS RATE OVER EXPECTED
5858
PACE
1111
PASS RATE
7878
EXPLOSIVENESS
66
FOURTH-DOWN AGGRESSION
1313
HAVOC
5454
HOW MUCH IDENTITY MOVES WITH A NEW STAFF
|Δ EXPLOSIVENESS|8.61%n=240
|Δ HAVOC|2.50%n=240
|Δ PASS RATE|5.18%n=240
|Δ PASS RATE OVER EXPECTED|5.24%n=87
|Δ PACE|1.63sn=240
MEDIAN ABSOLUTE SEASON-TO-SEASON SHIFT · 2016-2026 · MAGNITUDE, NOT DIRECTION — A NEW STAFF MOVES PASS RATE AND PACE BARELY MORE THAN A RETURNING ONE
MICHJIM HARBAUGH8TH SEASON2 SEASONS · 1 PROGRAMME
The programme's own prior season applies, under the same returning staff.
PASS RATE OVER EXPECTED
2828
PACE
4444
PASS RATE
55
EXPLOSIVENESS
2121
FOURTH-DOWN AGGRESSION
3535
HAVOC
9292
HOW MUCH IDENTITY MOVES WITH A RETURNING STAFF
|Δ PACE|1.37sn=929
|Δ EXPLOSIVENESS|6.72%n=931
|Δ HAVOC|2.10%n=929
|Δ PASS RATE|4.28%n=929
|Δ PASS RATE OVER EXPECTED|4.07%n=311
MEDIAN ABSOLUTE SEASON-TO-SEASON SHIFT · 2016-2026 · MAGNITUDE, NOT DIRECTION — A NEW STAFF MOVES PASS RATE AND PACE BARELY MORE THAN A RETURNING ONE
POSITION GROUPS — WHERE THE VOLUME LIVESMICH OFFENSEMSU OFFENSERETURNINGDEPARTED
COLLAPSE ALL
▾QBMICHIGAN OFFENSE
NATIONAL
23OF 133
TAL
93
PERF
69
RET
93
NATIONAL
79OF 133
RET
78
FULL DEFENSEMICHIGAN STATE DEFENSE
MICH QUARTERBACKSn=67% VACATED
QUARTERBACKS · PLAYED THIS SEASON FIRST
OVR
EXP
PT%
TAL
★REC
vsCOH
J.J. MCCARTHYQBRET
893RD YR9099★5+16
DAVIS WARRENQBRET
524TH YR2145★3—
ALEX ORJIQBRET
524TH YR245★3—
JACK TUTTLEQBPORTAL · INDIANA
514TH YR3128★3-9
JAYDEN DENEGALQBRET
504TH YR1317★3—
SHOW ALL 6
PARTICIPATION SHARE IS OF THIS ROOM · THESE SIX COLUMNS DESCRIBE THE ROSTER · UNIT-AGAINST-UNIT AND USAGE DETAIL IS ON THE MATCHUP TAB
MSU DEFENSE — GROUP GRADES3 ROOMS · 55 PLAYERS23% VACATED
DEFENSIVE ROOMS · GROUP GRADES
GRD
RET
BLU
DEFENSIVE LINEDL
5476%37%
LINEBACKERSLB
5271%21%
SECONDARYDB
4979%9%
THE QUARTERBACK PLAYS THE WHOLE SIDE — SHOWN AS ITS THREE ROOM GRADES, NOT MAN FOR MAN · PER PLAYER DETAIL LIVES IN THE OTHER DRAWERS
▾OLMICHIGAN OFFENSE
NATIONAL
38OF 133
TAL
92
PERF
59
RET
63
DL
58OF 133
DL RET
76
LB
58OF 133
LB RET
71
FRONT-7MICHIGAN STATE DEFENSE
MICH OFFENSIVE LINEn=2137% VACATED
FIVE-MAN LINE · PLAYED THIS SEASON FIRST
OVR
EXP
PT%
TAL
★REC
vsCOH
TREVOR KEEGANOLRET
834TH YR8793★4+39
DRAKE NUGENTOLPORTAL · STANFORD
864TH YR9492★4+46
ZAK ZINTEROLRET
844TH YR9090★4+48
GIOVANNI EL-HADIOLRET
694TH YR5397★4+30
TRENTE JONESOLRET
574TH YR6396★4+0
SHOW TOP 10
PARTICIPATION SHARE IS OF THIS ROOM · THESE SIX COLUMNS DESCRIBE THE ROSTER · UNIT-AGAINST-UNIT AND USAGE DETAIL IS ON THE MATCHUP TAB
MSU FRONT-7n=33 · 2 ROOMS26% VACATED
PASS RUSH · PLAYED THIS SEASON FIRST
OVR
EXP
PT%
TAL
★REC
vsCOH
JACOBY WINDMONLBRET
914TH YR6825★3-13
MAVERICK HANSENDLRET
864TH YR7444★3-32
SIMEON BARROW JR.DLRET
844TH YR8878★3+13
CAL HALADAYLBRET
704TH YR9860★3+3
DERRICK HARMONDLRET
663RD YR8595★4+5
SHOW TOP 10
THE DEFENDERS THIS ROOM FACES, BY GRADE · THESE SIX COLUMNS DESCRIBE THE ROSTER · PASS RUSH AND COVERAGE DETAIL LIVES ON THE MATCHUP TAB
▾RBMICHIGAN OFFENSE
NATIONAL
103OF 133
TAL
94
PERF
42
RET
97
DL
58OF 133
DL RET
76
LB
58OF 133
LB RET
71
FRONT-7MICHIGAN STATE DEFENSE
MICH RUNNING BACKSn=113% VACATED
BACKFIELD · PLAYED THIS SEASON FIRST
OVR
EXP
PT%
TAL
★REC
vsCOH
BLAKE CORUMRBRET
634TH YR10095★4+25
DONOVAN EDWARDSRBRET
524TH YR9199★4+15
KALEL MULLINGSRBRET
524TH YR4794★4+33
TAVIERRE DUNLAPRBRET
514TH YR279★3+19
LEON FRANKLINRBRET
494TH YR27—UNR-44
SHOW TOP 10
PARTICIPATION SHARE IS OF THIS ROOM · THESE SIX COLUMNS DESCRIBE THE ROSTER · UNIT-AGAINST-UNIT AND USAGE DETAIL IS ON THE MATCHUP TAB
MSU FRONT-72 ROOMS · 33 PLAYERS26% VACATED
ROOMS IN THE COMPOSITE
WT
GRD
RET
BLU
DEFENSIVE LINEDL
0.555476%37%
LINEBACKERSLB
0.455271%21%
EACH ROOM ON ITS OWN GRADE, NOT LISTED MAN FOR MAN · THE WEIGHTS DEFINE WHO PLAYS WHOM
▾WR/TEMICHIGAN OFFENSE
NATIONAL
51OF 133
TAL
86
PERF
57
RET
67
DB
77OF 133
DB RET
79
SECONDARYMICHIGAN STATE DEFENSE
MICH PASS CATCHERSn=2933% VACATED
PASS CATCHERS · PLAYED THIS SEASON FIRST
OVR
EXP
PT%
TAL
★REC
vsCOH
COLSTON LOVELANDTERET
843RD YR8688★4+20
ROMAN WILSONWRRET
714TH YR8786★4+30
AJ BARNERTEPORTAL · INDIANA
634TH YR9095★4-26
MAX BREDESONTERET
574TH YR44—UNR+11
PEYTON O'LEARYWRRET
514TH YR25—UNR—
SHOW TOP 10
PARTICIPATION SHARE IS OF THIS ROOM · THESE SIX COLUMNS DESCRIBE THE ROSTER · UNIT-AGAINST-UNIT AND USAGE DETAIL IS ON THE MATCHUP TAB
MSU SECONDARYn=22 · 1 ROOM21% VACATED
COVERAGE · PLAYED THIS SEASON FIRST
OVR
EXP
PT%
TAL
★REC
vsCOH
MALIK SPENCERDBRET
864TH YR7576★3+26
CHARLES BRANTLEYCBRET
584TH YR8078★3-29
KHALIL MAJEEDSRET
534TH YR42—UNR—
MARQUI LOWERY JR.DBRET
523RD YR2942★3—
SEAN BROWNDBTRUE FR
521ST YR2167★3—
SHOW TOP 10
THE DEFENDERS THIS ROOM FACES, BY GRADE · THESE SIX COLUMNS DESCRIBE THE ROSTER · PASS RUSH AND COVERAGE DETAIL LIVES ON THE MATCHUP TAB
RETURNINGPORTAL — PRIOR SCHOOL AND PORTAL STARS NAMEDLAST YR ≈ — RATES FROM HIS LAST MEASURED SEASON, NOT THE PROJECTED ROLEDEPARTEDVS COH = PRODUCTION vs OWN RECRUITING COHORT MEDIAN · CURVE = AHEAD / ON / BEHIND AT ±8 · PT% IS HIS SHARE OF HIS OWN ROOM · UNIT-AGAINST-UNIT AND USAGE DETAIL IS ON THE MATCHUP TAB
TEAM QUALITYHOUSE GRADE + REFERENCES
METRIC
MICH
FBS PCTL 0 ── 100
MSU
SCOUT TEAM GRADE
61.7
41.6
— OFFENSE
56.9
31.5
— DEFENSE
66.5
51.8
SP+ OVERALL
31.3
-6.8
FPI
27.6
-3.5
ELO
2210
1338
TALENT
850
747
PRODUCTION
100
33
TALENT − PRODUCTION ▾
−10
+47
BLUE CHIP RATIO
0.47
0.24
SCOUT TEAM GRADE DECOMPOSES INTO OFFENSE AND DEFENSE, EACH BUILT FROM THE POSITION ROOM GRADES ABOVE · ROOM WEIGHTS ARE MEASURED AGAINST UNIT EPA, NOT ASSUMED · SPECIAL TEAMS ARE NOT IN IT YET
FIVE FACTORSNATIONAL PERCENTILES
METRIC
MICH
FBS PCTL 0 ── 100
MSU
OFF EFFICIENCY
88
10
DEF EFFICIENCY
96
30
OFF EXPLOSIVENESS
26
12
DEF EXPLOSIVENESS
89
80
FINISHING DRIVES
90
7
FIELD POSITION
10
85
TURNOVER MARGIN
100
3
THE FIVE FACTORS ARE CORRELATED, NOT FIVE INDEPENDENT DIALS · TURNOVER MARGIN IS THE LEAST STABLE OF THEM YEAR OVER YEAR
TEAM IDENTITYTENDENCIES THAT SET VOLUME
METRIC
MICH
FBS PCTL 0 ── 100
MSU
PASS RATE
41.4%
53.6%
PROE
−0.8
+0.6
PACE
29.3s
29.6s
4TH-DOWN GO RATE
24%
19%
RUN RATE — STANDARD DNS
64.7%
55.3%
PASS RATE — PASSING DNS
57.9%
70.0%
PLAYS / GAME
61.5
60.8
GARBAGE TIME SHARE
2.3%
1.1%
EVERY ROW HERE IS COUNTED FROM PLAY BY PLAY · NONE OF IT IS A QUALITY RATING — FURTHER RIGHT IS MORE OF THE THING, NOT BETTER · SCHEME DETAIL LIVES ON THE MATCHUP TAB
EVERY PERCENTILE READS HIGH-IS-GOOD · CELL SHADE = FBS PERCENTILE OF THE VALUE · DOTS PLOT BOTH TEAMS ON ONE 0–100 TRACK (GOLD = MICH, ORANGE = MSU) · MEASURED FIGURES ARE 2023, GARBAGE-TIME FILTERED
≈ MARKS AN ESTIMATED VALUE · A CARRIED FIGURE IS WHAT A PLAYER DID LAST SEASON · PORTAL MARKS PARTICIPATION EARNED AT THE NAMED SCHOOL
VACATED VOLUME IS STATED AS OPEN AND NEVER ASSIGNED TO A SUCCESSOR · SPREAD, TOTAL, ML AND IMPLIED TOTALS ARE CONSENSUS MARKET FIGURES · NO PROJECTIONS ON THIS PAGE